Reader 5 (Middlesex University) bought out the debating side of me, 'Ethics is frequently not a case of black or white' I very much agree with this.
It is very inetersting to read that ethics can be categories to a certain extent into Personal, Profession, Organisation and society. After reading through the case studies I can now see this is the case. Ethics have been dated back to 300BC this ultimately gave the world a structure. Which was seen so early on as being vital in order for humans to co-exist. I wonder what the case under question was all those years ago which sparked ethics needing to come into play?
I have decided to blog some of my thoughts on the case studies in Reader 5, I think this may be useful when looking into my own professional practice ethics and give me some questions which I can apply, I have also given my opinion on the case studies.
Case Study 1- NHS Mid- Staffordshire Enquiry
- Can the NHS truly be disected by one man in one year? Surely the NHS did not go from 0 preventable deaths a year to 1,200 which triggered the enquiry - so where does the problem start and why did it start in the first place would this not take years of research into the future to establish if peoples actions are still causing it to happen?
- By Martin Yeates resigning before the report was published and being to ill to appear at the inquiry, the cynic in me point to this man knowing something and perhaps feeling guilty, was he not upholding the ethics and thinking he could get away with it?
- 'The NHS find it notoriously hard to admit a mistake' is this because it is public knowledge of how many problems the NHS has and if we knew the true extent would that be the end of the NHS?
- I think the ethical principles are professional and organizational however by individuals resigning they have made in personal. It would be easy to point the finger at the doctors and nurses that allowed the patients to die unnecessarily but why did they? lack of equipment? funding? training? staffing? These are all factors beyond their control so therefore the responsibility would lie higher up.
Case Study 2 - Ethics in Photography
This case study shocked me, to walk past an impoverished girl in order to take a photo of a vulture in flight is ludicrous! To me what gave that man the right to judge which life was more important if all human beings behaved this way with such disregard for others the world would cease to exsist.
They were told not to touch another human being for fear of epidemic? Could they not have alerted a medical team? Or at least bring water to the girl? Personally I would not be able to walk away from this situation
This is personal on the scale, not organisation or society, yes the organisation told him not to go near anyone, but would your human instinct not take over? That man chose to not help save another human life and I can see why in the end he died of guilt. Which ultimately isn't morally right either to let a wrong action eat you up so much, For me if i look back in hindsight at something and it was wrong i would do everything i could to make sure it certainly didn't happen again and something to help the situation. two lives were lost when neither needed to be.
Case Study 3 - The Dance Class
I can see both sides to this perhaps because I am a dance teacher so I am more informed, not doing a warm up does risk the dancers health and they could cause injury, im guessing that the teachers that were not doing warm ups have not had this happen to them, alternatively, for example when I have exam classes which are 30 mins long to take 10 mins doing a warm up and 5 mins at the end doing a cool down leaves me 15 mins to teach exam work and if the children don't get the results their parents want they don't come back! If the dance school is your livelyhood can you afford for this to happen- no. However if you extend the classes, this costs more. I don't but any means agree with not doing a warm up but I can see if under pressure why it was perhaps skipped. In the national curriculum it says all children must be involved and participate to do their best. By singling one student out and putting her down means she will not do her best. You learn to cope with the real world as you're living in it! Your real world may be very different to that of someone else. This is another problem in that anyone can go and open a dance school there is no regulations to stop them, however becoming a teaching is a long vigorous process. Therefore there will be difference in the codes of conduct which is a shame.
Case Study 4 - An extreme case of Plagiarism
Morally and Ethically wrong, personally, socially and oragazationally wrong.
A big question I have is how did the Spanish research team not think that Brown would speak up with evidence of his research and prove the the new planet was his discovery.
Having the same theory on something when researching the same thing could be quite common, for example some of the things I write about in my blog could be similar to someone else's without realising, but we are working on the same course from similar professional backgrounds.
However to pluck a theory such as a new planet from thin air with no back up research would set of alarm bells to most people.
Case Study 5 - Presenting findings
Alot of the findings have been made by presumption and generalisation not by fact. One persons opinion can be very different that of another disgregarding gender, class or age. However the author of these finding has drawn his own conclusions on the matter, reading the results of this I would say he hasn't actually spoken to these people and made this up himself.
He has described people politically incorrect as well as morally incorrect and disrepectful. These results I hope would not be taken seriously.
This has really helped me to many sides of ethics also to realise that its not just a case of right or wrong, not following rules and following rules. Does this mean when ethics comes under fire does it need to be a case by case inquiry, to be carried out by a number of people so that personal opinion doesn't come into play?
I feel most of my opinions have come from the world I have grown up in right from what I was taught as a child to the professional world I am now surrounded by, everyone has a different experience of this which is why codes of coduct would come in to play in a work place because the way you may deem appropriate to behave may not be the same a the place you are working in. It would be chaos to have everyone doing as they pleased but, this is a fine line between telling people what is expected of them and leaving them to work it out, rather than they telling them exactly what to think and how to go about doing it. If this was the way we would have difference of opinion.
This has made me realise why it is of such importance that ethics is taken into consideration when carrying out my inquiry as to not influence others opinions, disregard or group them.